Skip to content

Climatically robust multiscale species distribution models to support pronghorn recovery in California

Published Article

California

Publication date: June 20, 2024

View resource

A multimodel analysis identified current and future pronghorn habitat in California, revealing strong dependence on climate assumptions. Some models predict no future suitability, others expansion, but consensus habitat patches remain. Key data gaps—like thermal limits and migration history—must be resolved to guide recovery.

Subject Tags

  • Climate adaptation
  • Climate impacts
  • Biodiversity offsetting

Abstract

We combined two climate-based distribution models with three finer-scale suitability models to identify habitat for pronghorn recovery in California now and into the future. We used a consensus approach to identify areas of suitable climate now and future for pronghorn in California. We compared the results of climate models from two separate hypotheses about their historical ecology in the state. Under the migration hypothesis, pronghorn were expected to be limited climatically by extreme cold in winter and extreme heat in summer; under the niche reduction hypothesis, historical pronghorn of distribution would have better represented the climatic limitations of the species. We combined occurrences from GPS collars distributed across three populations of pronghorn in the state to create three distinct habitat suitability models: (1) an ensemble model using random forests, Maxent, classification and regression Trees, and a generalized linear model; (2) a step selection function; and (3) an expert-driven model. We evaluated consensus among both the climate models and the suitability models to prioritize areas for, and evaluate the prospects of, pronghorn recovery. Climate suitability for pronghorn in the future depends heavily on model assumptions. Under the migration hypothesis, our model predicted that there will be no suitable climate in California in the future. Under the niche reduction hypothesis, by contrast, suitable climate will expand. Habitat suitability also depended on the methods used, but areas of consensus among all three models exist in large patches throughout the state. Identifying habitat for a species which has undergone extreme range collapse, and which has very fine scale habitat needs, presents novel challenges for spatial ecologists. Our multimethod, multihypothesis approach can allow habitat modelers to identify areas of consensus and, perhaps more importantly, fill critical knowledge gaps that could resolve disagreements among the models. For pronghorn, a better understanding of their upper thermal tolerances and whether historical populations migrated will be crucial to their potential recovery in California and throughout the arid Southwest.

Citation

Bean, W.T., Butterfield, H.S., Howard, J.K. and Batter, T.J., 2024. Climatically robust multiscale species distribution models to support pronghorn recovery in California. Ecology and Evolution, 14(6), p.e11454. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.11454

TNC Authors