Influence of frameworks and data on climate risk estimates: A county-level analysis from Kenya
This study examines how frameworks and data sources influence climate risk estimates across Kenya's 47 counties. Using spatial analysis, climate data and socioeconomic indicators, researchers compare IPCC risk and vulnerability frameworks and global versus local datasets, revealing substantial differences in risk patterns and county rankings.
Subject Tags
- Climate risks
- Climate adaptation
- Social Sciences
Abstract
Accurate assessment of climate risk is essential for informing effective adaptation strategies, particularly in regions with high exposure and socioeconomic vulnerability. However, climate risk estimates can vary depending on the conceptual frameworks and data sources used. This study examines how different approaches influence the assessment of climate risk and vulnerability across Kenya at the county level. Using a geospatial analytical framework, we integrate historical climate data (Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index, SPEI), downscaled population data, and subnational sociodemographic indicators to generate spatially explicit risk profiles. We compare estimates derived from two different IPCC supported risk and vulnerability frameworks. Additionally, we construct and compare climate risk indices based on global and locally derived social vulnerability data. Our findings indicate that while both frameworks identify a similar set of high-risk counties, the magnitude and spatial distribution of risk and vulnerability differ substantially. Climate risk estimates show greater variability across counties, whereas vulnerability-based assessments appear more uniform. In addition, risk rankings vary depending on whether global or locally derived datasets are used, underscoring the sensitivity of results to input data. Locally derived vulnerability index captures greater subnational variation in climate risk. This study contributes to the limited body of research applying the IPCC risk framework in Africa and is among the first to systematically compare risk and vulnerability frameworks in the African context within a consistent analytical approach. These findings demonstrate that climate risk is not a fixed measure but is shaped by conceptual frameworks and data inputs, with important implications for climate adaptation planning, resource allocation, and policy prioritization in Kenya and similar contexts.
Citation
Mazumder, L.T., Kaur, M., Shyamsundar, P. et al. Influence of frameworks and data on climate risk estimates: A county-level analysis from Kenya. Theor Appl Climatol 157, 767 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00704-026-06608-x
TNC Authors
-
Priya Shyamsundar
Lead Economist
The Nature Conservancy
Email: priya.shyamsundar@tnc.org -
Luke Parsons
Associate Senior Climate Scientist
The Nature Conservancy
Email: luke.parsons@tnc.org -
Jared Gambo
Africa Climate Adaptation Specialist
The Nature Conservancy
Email: jared.gambo@tnc.org -
James Erbaugh
Associate Senior Social Scientist
The Nature Conservancy
Email: james.erbaugh@tnc.org -
Manpreet Kaur (Volunteer)
Applied Scientist I (IC)
The Nature Conservancy
Email: manpreet.kaur@tnc.org